Difference between revisions of "Nookipedia talk:Project Villager"

From Nookipedia, the Animal Crossing wiki
Line 82: Line 82:
  
 
I will not discuss the problem regarding the content of Villager/Gallery subpages that Paviinka has raised yesterday. It's a distinct problem, and I shall discuss it in the discussion she started above. --[[User:Ocre|Ocre]] ([[User talk:Ocre|talk]]) 18:57, March 21, 2020 (EDT)
 
I will not discuss the problem regarding the content of Villager/Gallery subpages that Paviinka has raised yesterday. It's a distinct problem, and I shall discuss it in the discussion she started above. --[[User:Ocre|Ocre]] ([[User talk:Ocre|talk]]) 18:57, March 21, 2020 (EDT)
 +
:Galleries as separate pages should be comprehensive as they need to be. If there is artwork only in a gallery, I'm guessing it's just a simple content gap or there's not enough images for a separate page anyway. Gallery pages, provided they are substantial, should be organized by artwork/sprites+models/screenshots/misc. Screenshots should be if the villager is a main focus (being talked to, inside their house), not if they're in the background.
 +
:Again, galleries should not be created if there is not enough artwork needed for a gallery ([[Phil]] wouldn't need a gallery, for instance, at least at revision I'm seeing). A point of a separate gallery page is to prevent the size of galleries overwhelming the main page (see [[Player/Gallery]] as an extreme example). Sometimes, it's at the editors' discretions; [[Cube]] can probably use a separate gallery page, but it's also not quite big enough to need a separate page. If we need to create a page for galleries, then the empty section that links to the gallery should have a small gallery of 3-5 images, preferably artwork.
 +
:Adding art in both the gallery and the main page is not a big problem. The only thing I can see it being a problem is if the gallery page is unnecessary. {{User:Mario/Sig}} 19:09, March 21, 2020 (EDT)

Revision as of 19:09, March 21, 2020

May I join the project?--Schapmond 23:11, 20 June 2013 (EDT)

Revive?

Some has to/I might. - HomerJC (talk) 16:26, July 25, 2015 (EDT)

I have my hands full on Project Furniture, but I expect an overhaul over this, since this is so old. Mario Signature.png 16:46, July 25, 2015 (EDT)
Project Furniture sounds more fun, I want to join! - HomerJC (talk) 17:01, July 25, 2015 (EDT)

Special Visitors

I have been reading through this and am wondering if you plan to include special visitors in this project or not? Articles pertaining to special visitors have intrigued me for awhile now (almost a year, actually), and I planned to eventually start a project focused on those characters (not the basic villagers). I do not know everything you intend to do, but if I were to head a project on special characters, which would incorporate any templates and layout designs you request be used, would you be cool with making the two projects the basis of something bigger (in other words, sister projects)? --XXSuperXXNintendoXx (talk) 23:49, August 10, 2015 (EDT)

Special visitors aren't a focus of this project, so I would definitely welcome a sister project if you wanted to focus on those pages. I would be more than happy to develop some templates for your project if needed or adapt any of the ones we're using to suit your needs. :) Sunmarshsignature.png (talk) 18:47, August 11, 2015 (EDT)

Album appearances?

Villagers make frequent appearances on album covers of K.K. songs, although the information is typically found in the trivia sections. I think they need a better spot in the article, maybe a parameter called "album appearances"? Mario Signature.png 16:52, August 14, 2015 (EDT)

Well, Template:Infobox Villager has an "other" parameter which is supposed to be used for appearances outside of the main series of games (e.g. 🎬 Gekijōban Doubutsu no Mori, Animal Crossing: Happy Home Designer etc.). It could also be used for album cover appearances and we could link to the KK song page? Alternatively I could potentially add it into Template:Villager Info. What do you think? Sunmarshsignature.png (talk) 17:00, August 14, 2015 (EDT)
Well, I'm not sure if we should list album cameos alongside spinoff appearances. I think you should add it to {{Villager Info}} instead as it seems to be better suited to covering trivial information. Finally, thinking about a response lead me to this: what about outside-series cameos, like appearances in Super Smash Bros. and Mario Kart 8? Mario Signature.png 17:12, August 14, 2015 (EDT)
That's a good question... I think that they should be noted in Template:Infobox Villager using the other parameter as well as in the "Other appearances" section of the villager's article page. I know that most of the outside-series appearances are of special characters/visitors though... which is a question that perhaps SNES should answer as he expressed interest in developing special visitor pages. I think that Template:Villager Info is the best candidate for the album cover info and will put that on my to-do list. Sunmarshsignature.png (talk) 17:22, August 14, 2015 (EDT)

Navigational template?

Sorry for potentially adding one more pain in the tailfeathers, but I suggest we unite all villagers under one navigational template. I suggest we organize within one giant list, alphabetized, since we can't organize by a trait without leaving out the other trait (e.g. organizing by species wouldn't take personality into account and vice-versa), and we already have such navigational aids at the top of the villager page. What do you think? Mario Signature.png 16:32, August 20, 2015 (EDT)

I'm not sure it would really aid much in navigation, considering how long the list would be. It would probably be easier for the user to type the name in the search box. I had considered creating some sort of navigation box using the species silhouettes though. You can see a mockup of this at the bottom of this page. They would each link to the appropriate species page with an extra silhouette linking the villager master list. Sunmarshsignature.png (talk) 16:56, August 20, 2015 (EDT)
I think it might be helpful to browse through multiple villagers without clicking on links or without having to type in the search bar. I do suppose the effort is mighty, though, and yeah, that navigational template is going to be huge. I like the species silhouettes, though, but it might be difficult to tell at a glance of what species is which, but maybe I'm wrong. Mario Signature.png 16:45, August 21, 2015 (EDT)

Personality descriptions

I think it would be a good idea to standardize personality descriptions by using a template. These sections often have variable quality for a nonunique trait, but still has, ultimately, the same information that's shared for villagers with that personality trait. Mario Signature.png 20:20, April 12, 2016 (EDT)

I agree with this. We should find an exemplary personality description of each type, or summarize the main article page and use that as the text for each villager of that personality type. I think a template would work great for this, something like {{pers|snooty}} for example, for snooty villagers. Sunmarshsignature.png (talk) 20:30, April 12, 2016 (EDT)
I've been actually thinking about using the existing {{pers}} template to accomplish this. I don't play Animal Crossing TOO much, so can you find any nuances of each personality, or do the main pages summarize them well enough? Mario Signature.png 20:43, April 12, 2016 (EDT)

amiibo Festival template

I was thinking that the villagers should have a template for their info in the various games in Animal Crossing: amiibo Festival. Some examples include in Desert Island Escape, where each character has a skill (wolves and tigers are lone wolves, kangaroos and koalas either move 7 or 0 spaces each turn e.t.c) and a favourite fruit ( Bud's are lemons for example). ZCJigglypuff(Talk) 05:02, June 20,2016 (EDT)

I agree that this information needs to be mentioned on the wiki in some form, but I'm not sure the best way to display it. In my opinion it seems a bit much to place info about a mini-game from an AC spin-off title onto each villager's page. I think that we definitely need a table for the info on the mini-game's main page though and we can go from there. A lot of information on the mini-game can be found in this guide.Sunmarshsignature.png (talk) 17:38, June 22, 2016 (EDT)

Villager Houses in New Leaf

Are we still trying to catalog the exterior of villager houses in Animal Crossing: New Leaf? If so, is it better to describe it or have a picture of it? ~PoizonMushro0mPoizonMush Sig.png 22:59, November 9, 2016 (EST)

Surely images will look better? However, there is already a blog on the internet somewhere that has a picture for every house exterior, so it'd look like we were copying them. But if we take our own images (good luck!), we should be okay. Red (talk)Red Snapper HHD Icon.png 11:36, November 10, 2016 (EST)

Primary image to use in article

Rosie HHD art

I'd like to bring up the primary image to use for a villager (i.e. the image that appears in the villager's infobox, the birthday section of the main page, etc.). Right now, the tendency seems to be to use whatever character art is available from the latest game. However, sometimes the character art from the latest game is low resolution, cropped out of another image, or something of the sort. For example, for Rosie, her HHD art is low resolution (119 × 231 pixels) and has heavily aliased borders. In cases like this I'd rather use a much higher-quality press image of Rosie from NL as her main image. I think this is important to give a clean look to the article, to the main page, to various Discord bots that use our images, and so on. Thoughts? ~SuperHamster Talk 00:57, June 27, 2018 (EDT)

Great idea, SH! The primary image is so prominent in an article that it should always be the highest quality image we have. Besides, can you call Happy Home Designer the latest game? I would say no, because it was a spin-off. Drago (talk) Drago PC Villager Icon.png 12:29, June 27, 2018 (EDT)

Gallery

Hi there,
not sure if this is still ongoing? But seemed like the perfect place for my question. I've been adding some sprites to galleries and I noticed that they're not all the same.

Sometimes, there's just a section "6 Gallery", eg. Bill - this contains a link to a gallery page (Bill/Gallery and below is gallery with artwork from games.
Other times, there's section "6 Gallery" and subsection "6.1 Artwork", eg. Drake. Under Gallery is the link to the gallery page and under artwork is the artwork, right.
And then there are also pages, that follow the "Ideal Table of Contents" as writen here, eg. Freckles.

My question is -why do some characters have Gallery pages and some do not? I thought it was that the oldest characters have Gallery pages (because they're probably having larger galleries), but that doesn't seem to be the case. (eg. Spike, though he was absent from WW/CF. Static has appeared in all games, and does not have a gallery page and has quite the number of pictures on the page.)
Personally I think it would be better if all character had gallery pages. Sure, sometimes, especially the new ones, have just 3 pictures in gallery so having a gallery page is probably unnecessary, but it'd look better, I think. I like the first example the most, I don't see the need for the "Artwork" subsection. (If the villager has a gallery page)

I was also wondering if it wouldn't look nicer if the "Sprites and Models" subsection was arranged the way that icons are next to each other and villager pics are next to each other and models are next to each other and so on. Now it's arranged by games, so Wild World icon is followed by WW picture, followed by album sprite, followed by more icons, eg. Lucy/Gallery. I think the other sections should be arranged by date, this one would just look better if it was arranged by a type... though that would ruin the consistency through subsections which might be weird?

I didn't want to ruin any standards that I'm missing being a baby editor on here so I'm asking which it is!
Thank you. ♥
Paviinka (talk) 02:57, March 20, 2020 (EDT)

Well, you stated there that some galleries are too small to have their own pages. Don't want really unnecessary page visiting. Also, it does seem like a nice idea to organize by type of image, with all head icons in one spot and pics in another, there are some stragglers such as album art, mugshots, and full body sprites that don't neatly fit. I suppose you can fit those into an extra subsection that deals with miscellaneous kinds of sprites, kind of like what we already do with the artwork section. Beyond Lucy's gallery, which I checked, would that set up work for enough amount of villagers?
And really, don't worry about "ruining" standards here. Please don't be afraid of bringing up any questions around here. Don't even be scared of attempting any edits since anything you might "mess up" on will be just reverted, and that's at worst. Thanks for dropping a comment here, and I hope you'll feel more confident the more you edit here! Mario Signature.png 03:16, March 20, 2020 (EDT)

Transcluding Gallery subpages content to villager pages

Hi ! We've had a good discussion with SuperHamster and Paviinka on the Discord regarding Gallery subpages and the lack of cohenrence between them, the villagers pages, and what gallery content should be shown on villager pages. A few points were raised :

  • It does not seem like there are any policy laid as to what images should be shown in the gallery section of villager pages : some show Artwork only, some show Artwork + Sprites + Miscellaneous, and some show even screenshots.
  • There is a problem regarding adding new villager pictures to Nookipedia. If you want to add them in the Villager/Gallery subpage, then you have double the work since you have to add them also on the villager's page proper.

So we have come up with an embryo of a policy.

  1. We've come up with the suggestion that only Artwork images should be shown on the villager pages
  2. SuperHamster said it was possible to have a transclude script that would fetch images in the Villager/Gallery subpage and show them on the villager's page, but only those of the section Artwork. That way we wouldn't have to work twice over - we would only work on the Villager/Gallery subpage when adding in new images.
  3. Since most of the images will now be stashed away in the Villager/Gallery subpages, the link to these subpages on villager pages should be made more proheminent - SuperHamster suggested a button or a something a bit more user-friendly?

I will not discuss the problem regarding the content of Villager/Gallery subpages that Paviinka has raised yesterday. It's a distinct problem, and I shall discuss it in the discussion she started above. --Ocre (talk) 18:57, March 21, 2020 (EDT)

Galleries as separate pages should be comprehensive as they need to be. If there is artwork only in a gallery, I'm guessing it's just a simple content gap or there's not enough images for a separate page anyway. Gallery pages, provided they are substantial, should be organized by artwork/sprites+models/screenshots/misc. Screenshots should be if the villager is a main focus (being talked to, inside their house), not if they're in the background.
Again, galleries should not be created if there is not enough artwork needed for a gallery (Phil wouldn't need a gallery, for instance, at least at revision I'm seeing). A point of a separate gallery page is to prevent the size of galleries overwhelming the main page (see Player/Gallery as an extreme example). Sometimes, it's at the editors' discretions; Cube can probably use a separate gallery page, but it's also not quite big enough to need a separate page. If we need to create a page for galleries, then the empty section that links to the gallery should have a small gallery of 3-5 images, preferably artwork.
Adding art in both the gallery and the main page is not a big problem. The only thing I can see it being a problem is if the gallery page is unnecessary. Mario Signature.png 19:09, March 21, 2020 (EDT)